The Uber Welfare State

At Columbia University, hungry students are encouraged to rely on the charity of their wealthy peers.


Columbia University is very rich. Its endowment is worth over $9 billion and its total assets are over $16 billion. Its annual revenues are nearly $4 billion. The land alone on its thirty-two-acre main campus is probably worth close to a billion at current rates for Manhattan land — and that doesn’t include buildings on the land, the uptown medical campus, or other holdings throughout one of the world’s most expensive real-estate markets. And yet it has some students who are going hungry because they’re too poor.

But the enterprising leaders of the student government have an idea: an Uber-like app that will allow rich students to share meals with their poorer colleagues. In a mass campus-wide email sent out last week, Ben Makansi and Viv Ramakrishnan, respectively student body president and VP of policy (!), announced a “two-pronged initiative.” After an arresting opening line, “Yes, we actually did some shit,” the duo, who ran a “satirical campaign,” disclosed the twin prongs of their “pilot plan.”

The first is “Swipes, a mobile app,” that is “like Uber for meal-sharing.” It will match donations of spare swipes on their meal cards by flush students to those in need of swipes. And the second is an “Emergency Meal Fund, a peer-funded meal bank,” which is presumably like an Indiegogo for the hungry, though they don’t invoke the obvious metaphor. The hungry will be able to claim up to six meals a semester, donated by their richer peers, with “no questions asked.” Six meals a semester isn’t very many for people who are seriously short of cash.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.