Rebuilding the Socialist Horizon

Bhaskar Sunkara reflects on the rise, defeat, and possible renewal of socialism — and on the generations of ordinary people who fought to build a world beyond class domination.

A Socialist Party rally at Madison Square Garden in New York City on May 1, 1938.

The people who built the socialist movement were not history’s fools. They were people who refused to accept the world as it was. (Victor Twyman / NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images)


Eric Aarons lived through the great defeats of the twentieth-century socialist movement but refused to let those defeats have the last word. He joined the Communist Party of Australia as a young man. He believed, as millions did across the world, that he was on the right side of history. He watched, over decades, as history played out in reality — as Stalinism revealed its horrors, as the official Communist movement broke apart, as the social democratic compromise in the West frayed and was finally torn up. But he kept struggling for a better world. Not through moving back to the certainties of his youth, and not through moving forward into the accommodations of centrist politics, but by trying to move toward a new politics.

That is the spirit in which I want to speak tonight. Because we are gathered as socialists, as trade unionists, as people who want to live in a better world, decades after socialism was declared dead. Indeed, the socialist movement that millions of workers across the world built over 150 years — the parties, the unions, the cooperatives, the newspapers, the cultural institutions, the experiments in workers’ power and public ownership — is either gone or hollowed out.

But we should insist to the world that socialism was not wrong. Socialism suffered defeats.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.