Centrist Democrats Keep Making Awful Health Reform Proposals
The centrist Searchlight Institute has released a health care policy proposal with the hope that Democratic candidates will adopt it. The grab bag of policies is internally contradictory and cruel in places — and fails to insure everyone.

The new health care policy from the Searchlight Institute doesn’t make sure all Americans are covered and does little to nothing to cut down on costs. It is clearly inferior to Medicare for All. (Anthony Souffle / Minnesota Star Tribune via Getty Images)
As the start of the 2028 Democratic presidential primary nears, various policy institutions will offer up health care proposals for candidates to adopt. One such organization, the Searchlight Institute, jumped the gun a few months ago when it released Making Health Care More Available, a package of reforms headlined by a proposal to make primary care free for everyone. Overall, I find the Searchlight Institute’s proposal to be generally overstated in its significance and quite strange and cruel in its particulars.
Free Primary Care for All
Whenever someone goes to the doctor, the bill they receive is paid either directly by them out of pocket, by their insurer, or through some combination of the two. The precise payment mix is determined by the cost-sharing rules contained in health insurance plans, which vary from policy to policy.
The Affordable Care Act established a list of ten essential health benefits (EHBs) that must be covered entirely by health insurers without any out-of-pocket cost-sharing for individuals. The Searchlight proposal would simply add primary care services as the eleventh EHB.