Israel Is Undermining the Struggle Against Antisemitism
Controversy about the meanings of antisemitism, especially in relation to Israel, has become one of the major flash points in contemporary politics. Mark Mazower’s invaluable history of the concept deserves to be a touchstone in the debate.

The fight against antisemitism is hindered, not helped, by its instrumentalization to serve foreign policy ends and domestic culture wars. (Photo by Marc Israel Sellem / Pool / AFP via Getty Images)
Mark Mazower has written a stunner of a book: informed, questioning, probing, thought-provoking, and highly readable. On Antisemitism tackles one of the most fraught political questions of our time, informed by Mazower’s background as a leading historian of modern Europe.
Words shift and change their meaning over time and place. Raymond Williams’s Keywords, alluded to by Mazower, is a “vocabulary of culture and society” running though the shifts and changes in around 130 keywords — art, class, exploitation, family, hegemony, industry, violence, welfare, and many more. Were Wiliams alive to revise the book today, there is no doubt that he would include “antisemitism,” together with a range of other cognate keywords with which it is now inevitably associated: Zionism, Israel, anti-Zionist, “the Jewish people.”
It is appropriate that Mazower’s introduction to the concept of antisemitism should start with the word “confusion” in its introduction and head it with a quotation from Lewis Carroll: “‘That’s a great deal to make one word mean,’ Alice said in a thoughtful tone.” As Mazower points out, changes in meaning may “catch us by surprise.” This book provides a case study of one such change.