Budgeting Scolds Are Gaslighting Struggling Americans

The affluent often blame poverty on bad budgeting skills, claiming the poor just need to be taught financial literacy. But working-class people require living wages and a functioning safety net, not condescending lectures about money management.

Senate Health Committee Hears Testimony From Fired CDC Director Susan Monarez

Last week, Ohio Senator Jon Husted condescendingly blamed his constituents’ poverty on bad budgeting skills. But research shows the exact opposite: working-class people know the value of a dollar and are way less likely to overspend than the rich. (Kevin Dietsch / Getty Images)


Speaking on a conservative podcast last week, Senator Jon Husted confidently asserted that low-income people can’t handle daily challenges and lack basic budgeting skills. “People living in poverty are just not very experienced at navigating the real world, right?” said Husted, a Republican representing Ohio who is facing a November election, likely against former Senator Sherrod Brown.

“I remember talking to one young lady who said, ‘Well, I don’t really know how money works at a grocery store,’ because she grew up and has lived all of her adult life using SNAP [Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program] cards to buy groceries,” Husted continued. “So you literally have to teach people how to budget.”

Husted’s comments drew criticism from Brown and others. Deservedly so. But his statements reflect an attitude held by far more people than one out-of-touch politician. Husted’s condescension about poor Americans permeates the government and many nonprofit organizations. In these environments, it’s common to hear that people endure poverty not because they don’t have enough money but because they don’t manage their money properly. This myth is often packaged as a call for “financial literacy.”

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.