How Israel Succeeded Where South Africa Failed
Bantustans without borders, occupation without formal annexation, and a dual legal system that cements ethnic hierarchy. In Gaza and the West Bank, Israel has refined a model of enthonational control that apartheid-era South Africa struggled to sustain.

A mother and her daughter seen passing in front of an Israeli military vehicle during a raid at the Balata refugee camp in the West Bank. (Nasser Ishtayeh / SOPA Images / LightRocket via Getty Images)
While the world watches in horror as Palestinians are killed at food distribution sites in Gaza, Israel is quietly accelerating its long-anticipated plan to annex parts of the occupied West Bank.
Emboldened by Western diplomatic cover, Israeli authorities have intensified efforts to displace Palestinians and entrench Jewish-Israeli control — what Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich has referred to as the “Judaization” of the area. This campaign has involved home demolition, forced evictions, and the construction of Jewish-only settlements, outlined by exclusive cooperation bylaws.
The Knesset’s recent passing of legislation facilitating the annexation of the West Bank is the culmination of a multidecade strategy to gradually reshape its ethnic demography through the expansion of illegal Jewish settlements. Settlers often act with impunity, carrying out frequent and often violent attacks on Palestinian communities.