Boycotting Russian Dissidents Is Only Helping Vladimir Putin

Anti-Russian boycotts in the West are hitting even outspoken opponents of Vladmir Putin’s war. Collective punishment is deeply unfair — and only hardens Putin’s grip over Russians.

RUSSIA-UKRAINE-CONFLICT-TV-PROTEST

A woman looks at a computer screen, watching dissenting Russian Channel One employee Marina Ovsyannikova interrupting Russia’s most-watched evening news broadcast, holding up a poster that reads “No War” and condemning Russia’s military action in Ukraine in Moscow on March 15, 2022. (AFP via Getty Images)


My birth certificate reads: “Mother: Tatar; Father: Russian.” For reasons involving alcohol abuse, my father played no role in my life, and I was raised entirely by my mother’s side of the family. When I was little, I used to think my great-grandmother wasn’t very intelligent, as she spoke Russian in a strange way and exclusively used the male gender. Only later did I realize that Russian wasn’t her first language; it was Tatar. Only later did my mother tell me about the discrimination our family faced as an ethnic minority in Russia and her own experiences of being referred to as a “filthy Asian” — too narrow-eyed, too skinny, too dark.

When she signed up for a dating firm to find a husband in the West, it was recommended she dye her hair blonde before taking professional photographs for the online profile. Only later did I understand why my own Tatar identity was hushed, in favor of emphasizing that I am Russian.

On the day that Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, I returned from demonstrating at the Russian consulate and the United Nations and posted a story on my Instagram. I described my struggle with Russian identity, my effort to assimilate to Dutch culture when my mother and I immigrated to the Netherlands, how I felt that I could only come out as lesbian once I denounced my Russianness, how I’ve felt ashamed of being Russian for most of my life. This changed when I started to engage with queer culture in Russia, allowing myself to imagine an alternative future for the country. But that hope shattered all over again when Putin invaded Ukraine — leaving nothing but an overwhelming sense of shame. I was aware that this post risked “making it all about me,” but I also felt that the personal was my only entryway into the political. Not only am I far from an expert in foreign policy — and amazed by how easily others pretend to be — but I believe that that the violent suppression of queer voices, within the wider gagging of any opposition, has been one of Putin’s most successful strategies for stabilizing his rule.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.