The Rise of Hindu Nationalism and the Failures of the Indian Left

India’s once-powerful left-wing movements are facing the gravest challenge in their history as Narendra Modi’s ultranationalist party consolidates its grip on power. This moment of crisis calls for a wholesale rethink of theory and strategy by Indian socialists.

Narendra Modi Campaigns Before India's General Election

BJP supporter holding up an image of Narendra Modi at a public rally in Kolkata, India, 2019. (Atul Loke / Getty Images)


India’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), firmly entrenched in power, is pursuing a vendetta against its enemies — in particular, Indian Muslims and the country’s left-wing movement. Leading figures of the Indian left have been arrested under repressive legislation such as the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) and branded as “Urban Naxalites.” Citizenship laws have targeted Muslims, stripping them of legal status.

There have been big demonstrations against these discriminatory laws by Muslims and student activists. Narendra Modi’s government used the pandemic curfew as an excuse to clamp down on such protests, and the authorities subsequently arrested some of the organizers, accusing them of having instigated the Delhi riots in February. But where have India’s left parties been while this was happening?

The Indian left is at a low ebb, probably the worst moment in its history. The mainstream, parliamentary left, represented by the Communist Party of India and the Communist Party of India (Marxist), has no vision of anti-capitalist struggle, and is losing its electoral base. The Maoist organizations are confined to the forests of central India, isolated by their political sectarianism.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.