On Day One, Trump Wasn’t the Dictator He Promised to Be

Donald Trump promised to be “a dictator on day one.” Instead, his barrage of executive orders is largely an organized pursuit of his campaign pledges — with a noticeable lack of action on tariffs and immigration raids thus far.

Trump To Announce New AI Investment Push With OpenAI, Softbank, Oracle

Donald Trump speaks at the White House in Washington, DC, on January 21, 2025. (Aaron Schwartz / Sipa / Bloomberg via Getty Images)


Before the election, much was made of Donald Trump’s promise to be “a dictator on day one.” Trump’s critics and Trump himself said his medium would be executive orders — but this time used not as an ordinary instrument of policy-making so much as an extraordinary instrument of extra-constitutional governing.

In any event, the first executive orders of Trump’s second administration are largely an organized pursuit of his campaign pledges. They amount to a somewhat bolder exercise of presidential power than is customary for an incoming president, but nothing approaching the exercise of dictatorial power.

The seeming exception is the order abolishing birthright citizenship, which sounds straightforwardly unconstitutional and seems likely to be struck down by courts. In that case, the measure of whether or not it is an example of dictatorial power comes down to whether he is willing to directly confront the courts. There’s little chance of that. Trump himself has said it will be up to the courts — not exactly how a dictator talks. In reality, the birthright order is a win-win sop to his base: if upheld, he gets what he wanted; if struck down, then he did what they wanted. And if the courts do approve the order, it becomes part of that long, dark tradition of the courts putting a legal stamp on the extension and expansion of presidential power.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.