Banks Profit From High Interest Rates but Stiff Depositors

With the help of the Federal Reserve, US banks are offering loans at higher rates than the interest they pay to depositors and pocketing the difference for themselves.

JPMorgan Chase charged roughly 7 percent interest for mortgages and 18 to 27 percent interest for credit cards in 2022 while paying its customers a .01 percent rate on a demand-deposit account — pocket change compared to the bank’s $128 billion in revenue that year. (Al Drago / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

With the help of the Federal Reserve, banks are offering loans at higher rates than the interest they pay to depositors and pocketing the difference for themselves.

This so-called net interest income is a wildly lucrative scheme for banks that’s only growing more profitable: a new Fed report finds that last quarter, banking margins “benefited from increasing yields on earning assets, particularly loans . . . [as] funding costs remained stable.” Effectively, banks are making more money off interest from loans while paying the same or less to depositors.

Recent data from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, an independent agency that backs bank deposits, finds that the average interest rate US banks pay to depositors on their savings accounts is 0.4 percent, while the government pays those same banks 4.3 percent for loans.

The difference between what banks are making and charging in interest has hit a “modern high” in recent years, meaning depositors are missing out on potentially billions of dollars in wealth because many corporate banks have kept their interest rates absurdly low.

Because there are no guarantees or requirements that banks pass on high interest rate benefits to depositors, the Fed’s high interest rates have overwhelmingly benefited financial institutions — creating a $1 trillion windfall.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) has called out banks over their net interest profits. As she pointed out, JPMorgan Chase charged roughly 7 percent interest for mortgages and 18 to 27 percent interest for credit cards in 2022 while paying its customers a .01 percent rate on a demand-deposit account — pocket change compared to the bank’s $128 billion in revenue that year.

“While the deposit rate for savers always lags the federal funds rate, this gap is far more pronounced for customers of big banks than for regional and community banks,” Warren notes.

A February report from consulting giant McKinsey urged banks to further squeeze depositors by using artificial intelligence to identify “hidden affluence” and offer personalized promotional interest rates to wealthier consumers who are more likely to switch financial institutions strategically.

In other words, banks rip off millions of working people — depositing relative pennies into most accounts — while offering more lucrative interest yields to richer depositors.

But good news could be on the horizon: at the urging of cryptocurrency allies, Donald Trump has revived a Biden-era open banking rule despised by banks because it’s designed to help Americans shop for better interest rates.

This article was first published by the Lever, an award-winning independent investigative newsroom.

Share this article

Contributors

Veronica Riccobene is a reporter with the Lever based in Washington, DC. She has experience in live television, long form, and vertical video as well as reporting.

David Sirota is editor-at-large at Jacobin. He edits the Lever and previously served as a senior adviser and speechwriter on Bernie Sanders’s 2020 presidential campaign.

Filed Under