How Hollywood’s Anti-Communist Crackdown Made TV and Movies Bland and Boring

The conformity of 1950s film and television was the result of the successful McCarthyist purge of leftists — and their genres — from the entertainment industry. The life of socialist screenwriter Very Caspary shows how it was done and what was lost.

"Laura" Film Still

Actress Gene Tierney and Vincent Price in Laura. (Donaldson Collection / Getty Images)


The current Writers Guild of America strike reminds us of the lasting effects of major political and labor action in the entertainment industry on the kind of material that gets produced. The most dramatic instance of this is, of course, the 1950s McCarthyist red-baiting, which resulted in the Hollywood blacklist. Not only did the anti-communist witch hunts directly alter the course of hundreds of lives, but they also radically impacted film and television as a medium — and, consequently, the whole culture.

The conformity and conservatism of the 1950s were manifest across all mainstream media, but especially in sanitized television shows celebrating the American, white, middle-class nuclear family — think Leave It to Beaver, Father Knows Best, and The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet. These shows imprinted themselves on the conservative political imagination. When politicians urge us, as Ronald Reagan did when first running for president, to “make America great again,” the ideal in their minds is the one modeled by these fantasy shows.

But contrary to popular understanding, the conservatism of the ’50s isn’t simply “old-fashioned.” It came on the heels of a somewhat more progressive period in film and television, which drew to a close with the intensification of Hollywood red-baiting.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.