How Capitalism Remade Homophobia

Chris Nealon
Max Fox

Before tragically dying at age 32, Chris Chitty, a brilliant historian of gay life and capitalism, produced an illuminating unfinished book, Sexual Hegemony. In it, he provided a longue durée account of the development of homophobia and homosexuality.

Italy, Venice, Scenes from life of Saint Ursula (from Golden Legend by Jacobus de Voragine) Arrival of English Ambassadors, detail harbour

Scene of a Venetian harbor during the Italian Renaissance, illustrated by Vittore Carpaccio (ca. 1460–1526). (DEA / G. Dagli Orti / De Agostini via Getty Images)


Across the political spectrum, it has become somewhat of a bromide to argue that sexuality is socially constructed. Leftists defend social constructivism in order to undermine essentializing ideas about sexuality, and reactionaries do so in order to wage a war on what they view as gender ideology. Rarely do people take this fact as an opportunity to develop an understanding of sexuality as something shaped by the transformation of economic and social relations.

Before dying tragically at age thirty-two, Christopher Chitty, a PhD student in the History of Consciousness Department at University of California, Santa Cruz, wrote a brilliantly original but unfinished book, Sexual Hegemony. In it he produced an imaginative fusion of the epoch-stretching world systems theory of the historical sociologists Giovanni Arrighi and the French philosopher Michel Foucault’s ideas about sexuality to ask a fundamental question: How has capitalism shaped the emergence of both homophobia and homosexuality? For Jacobin Radio’s The Dig podcast, editor Max Fox and contributor Chris Nealson spoke to Daniel Denvir about these complex issues. You can find the episode here.


Daniel Denvir

We should start this interview by talking about Christopher Chitty, the author of the remarkable book we’re discussing. Who was Chris and what was his project?

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.