No, There Is No Such Thing as the Undeserving Poor

Former Liberal Party minister Pru Goward recently published an opinion piece outlining her views on the “underclass.” Her analysis exemplifies the ignorance, mediocrity, and condescension of Australia’s elite.

Old homeless man

Pru Goward’s rehash of offensive stereotypes about poor people attracted widespread condemnation in Australia. (Getty Images)


In October this year, the Australian Financial Review published an opinion piece entitled “Why you shouldn’t underestimate the underclass” by former Liberal Party minister Pru Goward. The underclass is, according to Goward, “damaged, lacking in trust and discipline,” and “highly self-interested.”

In Australia, Goward’s op-ed attracted widespread condemnation for spreading offensive stereotypes about poor people — and rightly so. The piece is a muddled exercise in bashing working-class Australians; its arguments are intellectually incoherent and empirically unsupported.

Of course, these are the kinds of invectives that we have come to expect from garden-variety Liberal Party ideologues like Andrew Bolt or Peta Credlin. But Prue Goward is no shock jock; she is part of the social policy elite. She served as a minister in the New South Wales state government from 2011 to 2019, after which Western Sydney University appointed her Professor of Social Interventions and Policy.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.