Why Socialists Should Distrust Antitrust

People are right to be disgusted by giant corporations. But the liberal “antitrust” response too often valorizes small-scale competition instead of solidarity and worker organization.

IRS Commissioner Rettig Testifies To Senate On 2022 Budget

No other politician has been more associated with the antitrust case than Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts. (Evelyn Hockstein-Pool / Getty Images)


Last week, Joe Biden tweeted, “Let me be clear: capitalism without competition isn’t capitalism. It’s exploitation.”

It would be too much to expect this rather dim politician to understand, much less endorse, the classic Marxist analysis of profit originating in the exploitation of workers — they produce more in value for their employer than they’re paid in wages. But the remark, in all its naiveté, does capture a spreading belief in liberal policy circles that monopoly is at the heart of our economic troubles, from crappy jobs to crappy pay and benefits. I’m not convinced.

According to the introductory economics I learned in college — which was admittedly long ago — two essential features of monopolized markets were high prices and restricted supply. Those features weren’t at all visible in the US economy until the pandemic began messing with supply chains, resulting in short supplies in some sectors in the face of pent-up demand, demand that was supercharged with stimulus checks.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.