Keeping Power Utilities in Corporate Hands Doesn’t Make Sense

A new study shows that socialist plans to take over the privately owned power utility in New York’s Hudson Valley would lower rates for users and improve its long-term health. Public ownership of power companies is better for everyone but the rich.

Tower carrying PSEG Long Island transmission lines silhouette the setting sun

Average New Yorkers are hurting as utility bills keep going up. Public takeovers of power companies offer one way to bring those bills down. (John Paraskevas / Newsday RM via Getty Images)


All over the country, Americans are struggling to pay their utility bills. In the Hudson Valley, the situation is particularly dire, with some ratepayers coping with surprise monthly bills of thousands of dollars. It doesn’t have to be that way, according to the region’s democratic socialists, who are leading a fight to lower prices.

A bill introduced by Sarahana Shrestha, a democratic socialist assemblywoman in Assembly District 103 in the Mid-Hudson Valley, and her state senate colleague, Michelle Hinchey, calls for a state takeover of the utility company serving the area. A feasibility study by NewGen Strategies and Solutions, commissioned by the Hudson Valley Public Power Coalition, says a public takeover would provide millions in savings to New York State and its ratepayers.

According to the study’s projections, a publicly owned utility — unlike a private company — would no longer have to pay state and local taxes or make profit for its shareholders, allowing it to save $15.2 million in its first year alone. After that, the savings keep growing: $34.4 million by year five, $56.2 million by year ten, $116.8 million by year twenty, and $210.5 million by year thirty. These savings would allow the utility to lower costs to ratepayers. It would also allow for more stability, making billing more predictable for consumers and fund much-needed repairs to infrastructure.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.