These Remote Islands’ Tax System Shows Why Universal Benefits Are Better Than Means-Testing

The US could learn from the Faroe Islands, a Danish territory where the state automatically removes taxes owed and adds welfare payments to workers’ paychecks. It’s way easier for workers and shows why universal benefits are better than means-testing.

Houses on the coast in the Faroe Islands, 2019. (Wikimedia Commons)


Many years ago, I learned that the Faroe Islands has a peculiar process for compensating workers. There, employers pay each worker’s entire paycheck to the tax authority, which removes any taxes owed and then remits the remainder to each worker’s linked bank account. As part of this process, the tax authority also rolls in any welfare payments an individual is owed when making its periodic payments.

I found this system fascinating for many reasons:

  1. It has clear benefits for employers as they no longer have to manage tax withholdings or hire a third-party firm to do it for them.

  2. It has clear benefits for individuals as they never overpay or underpay their taxes and therefore don’t have to deal with any end-of-year tax reconciliation.

  3. It has clear benefits for managing the economy because it generates nearly real-time, whole-economy data about employment, wages, and incomes.

  4. It has clear benefits for welfare administration, as it automatically collects the information that goes into the calculation of certain benefits like unemployment insurance. It also makes it trivial for the welfare state to reach every person in the country, such as in the event of an acute recession where stimulus may be necessary.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.