The Agony and the Ecstasy of Vancouver, British Columbia

Vancouver consistently earns top ranks in international livability indexes, yet it is brutally unaffordable. A new book plumbs the city’s history, revealing how past tensions between its elites and masses define its present — and may shape its future.

Railway Yards of Vancouver

A 1964 aerial view of Vancouver’s railyards, which helped to make the city a global imperial trade hub in the 19th and 20th centuries. (Bettmann Archive via Getty Images)


In the 1960s, the citizens of Vancouver, a Pacific port city in the Canadian province of British Columbia, rebelled against the “North American disease of proliferation and gigantism.” The collapse of plans to build urban freeways was followed by the rehabilitation of the city’s peninsular downtown, the deindustrialization of the shoreline, and finally the pursuit of the “world’s greenest city” status through the construction of bike lanes and expansion of the SkyTrain transit system.

By the time the city hosted the 2010 Winter Olympics, Vancouver had spawned “Vancouverism” — a concept and a brand. Vancouverism meant “city building in paradise.” Hemmed in by mountains and the Burrard Inlet to the north, bisected by False Creek and bordered by the Fraser River to its south, the city of Vancouver had no choice but to grow responsibly, which meant upward. Planners controlled the flow of developer capital after a successful World’s Fair — Expo 86 — by mandating clusters of green-glass condo towers for former industrial areas, mounted on podiums of shops to keep the street scene lively. What one book called The Vancouver Achievement pushed the city up the Economist’s global “livability” index, where it still sits in fifth place, alongside other cities from the former British Dominions. While paying polite heed to that “achievement,” Daniel Francis’s concise and vividly illustrated Becoming Vancouver also invites us to consider the related costs, and how the city’s history might provide new ideas for how to overcome the deep social problems it has failed to address.

The Curse of “Livable” Cities

It can be hard to survive in so-called livable cities. Vancouver is “world-class” mainly in its housing costs. In 2021, the Vancouver Sun reported that the median price for a Vancouver property was thirteen times the local median income, putting the city just behind Hong Kong and Sydney in unaffordability rankings. Costs and vacancy rates have been just as brutal for renters, pushing old and new Vancouverites to settle in car-dependent sprawl beyond the city. If Vancouverism discouraged the middle class, then it was tougher still on the welfare class, which it concentrated into the Downtown Eastside. Here decrepit hotels built for miners and loggers now house single room occupancy (SRO) buildings. It is not livability which flourishes in SROs but mortality. They are the epicenter of British Columbia’s fentanyl epidemic, which has in 2022 alone killed 1,468 people.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.