John Fetterman’s Post-Stroke Struggles Are Brave. They’re Also Irrelevant.

John Fetterman’s post-stroke impairment is temporary, it doesn’t affect his cognitive capacity, and plenty of sitting senators have suffered from much worse. So why is his condition getting more attention than his opponent’s sleazy history?

Democratic candidate for US Senate John Fetterman reacts to applause from supporters during a joint rally with Democratic candidate for governor Pennsylvania attorney general Josh Shapiro at Norris Park on October 15, 2022, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Mark Makela / Getty Images)


Progressives just can’t seem to catch a break. Pennsylvania lieutenant governor John Fetterman seemed to offer left-leaning Democrats just the kind of candidate who many had argued could win elections in situations where typical Democrats couldn’t: a plainspoken populist who looked and talked like a regular person and who could appeal to both high-education Democratic partisans and the kind of disillusioned Rust Belt voters who went for Donald Trump six years ago.

Then he had a stroke.

A little over a week before the midterms, Fetterman’s near-death experience, which took place five months ago, has perhaps become the issue of his Senate race against Republican and daytime talk show host Dr Oz, which has narrowed recently. If nothing else, it’s certainly become the focus of media coverage of the race, ever since Fetterman sat down for an interview with NBC two weeks ago, giving the country a firsthand look at the extent of the damage the stroke had left on the once front-runner.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.