Another Europe is Possible – But Not Another European Union

Europe’s radical left has been bitterly divided over the question of European integration. But wishful thinking aside, the structures of the European Union can’t be used to achieve socialist goals. Sooner or later, any left government will have to confront and defy its economic straitjacket.

Syriza Party Rally Before This Weekend's General Election

Alexis Tsipras, leader of Syriza, campaigns at a pre-election rally on January 22, 2015 in Athens, Greece.Matt Cardy / Getty


There’s a strange monument to European unity on Barcelona’s Montjuic hill: big stone slabs, with a quote from the Treaty of Rome in Catalan, and the dates of birth and death for a series of European notables, ranging from founding fathers of the European Union like Jean Monnet, to national politicians like Winston Churchill, Willy Brandt, and Francois Mitterrand.

But there’s a surprising addition to their ranks: Rosa Luxemburg. The inclusion of this Polish-German revolutionary would no doubt have bemused her contemporary Churchill, who denounced Luxemburg for belonging to a “sinister conspiracy” of “international Jews,” drawn from “the underworld of the great cities of Europe and America,” who were seeking to overthrow Western civilization.

The gulf between Luxemburg and Churchill was scarcely greater than the gulf between her political vision and that of the present-day European Union. However, there’s one group in the European parliament that claims direct descent from Luxemburg’s ideas: the various strands of Europe’s radical left. Is their position at the heart of the European project as incongruous as Luxemburg’s presence on Montjuic? Or can the radical left somehow bend that project to its purposes?

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.