Something Has to Give

The latest figures show that more and more young people are taking on higher and higher levels of student debt.

Aaron R Hawkins / Flickr


Using the latest Survey of Consumer Finances, I broke out student debt levels by student debt percentiles below. This is a more comprehensive look at student debt trends than the medians and means you usually see. (Hover your cursor over the graph to get a list of values at each percentile.)

(function(){ function include(script, next) {var sc=document.createElement("script");sc.src = script;sc.type="text/javascript";sc.onload=function() {if (++next < incl.length) include(incl[next], next);};document.head.appendChild(sc);}function each(a, fn){if (typeof a.forEach !== "undefined"){a.forEach(fn);}else{for (var i = 0; i < a.length; i++){if (fn) {fn(a[i]);}}}}var inc = {},incl=[]; each(document.querySelectorAll("script"), function(t) {inc[t.src.substr(0, t.src.indexOf("?"))] = 1;});each(Object.keys({"https://code.highcharts.com/stock/highstock.js":1,"https://code.highcharts.com/adapters/standalone-framework.js":1,"https://code.highcharts.com/highcharts-more.js":1,"https://code.highcharts.com/highcharts-3d.js":1,"https://code.highcharts.com/modules/data.js":1,"https://code.highcharts.com/modules/map.js":1,"https://code.highcharts.com/modules/exporting.js":1,"http://code.highcharts.com/modules/funnel.js":1,"http://code.highcharts.com/modules/solid-gauge.js":1}),function (k){if (!inc[k]) {incl.push(k)}});if (incl.length > 0) { include(incl[0], 0); } function cl() {if(typeof window["Highcharts"] !== "undefined"){Highcharts.setOptions({lang:{"thousandsSep":","}});var options={"options":{},"chart":{"type":"line","height":506},"exporting":{"enabled":false},"title":{"style":{"fontSize":"14px"},"text":"Student Debt Level by Percentile (Age 18-35)"},"tooltip":{"shared":true,"valuePrefix":"$"},"xAxis":[{"title":{"text":"Student Debt Percentile"}}],"legend":{"align":"right","verticalAlign":"middle","layout":"vertical"},"credits":{"text":"Source: Survey of Consumer Finances","href":"https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scfindex.htm"},"yAxis":[{"title":{"text":"2016 Dollars"}}],"series":[{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,1000],[57,2000],[58,2900],[59,3100],[60,4000],[61,4700],[62,5000],[63,5400],[64,6000],[65,6800],[66,7500],[67,8800],[68,9700],[69,10000],[70,11000],[71,11800],[72,13000],[73,14000],[74,15000],[75,16000],[76,17000],[77,17500],[78,19000],[79,20000],[80,22000],[81,23700],[82,25000],[83,26000],[84,29000],[85,30000],[86,32000],[87,35000],[88,38000],[89,40000],[90,44000],[91,46000],[92,50000],[93,57000],[94,65000],[95,70000],[96,78000],[97,90000],[98,114000],[99,150000],[100,null]],"name":"2016","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,825],[60,1031],[61,1547],[62,2578],[63,3093],[64,4124],[65,4743],[66,5156],[67,5671],[68,6496],[69,7733],[70,8249],[71,9280],[72,10311],[73,10311],[74,11342],[75,12889],[76,13714],[77,15467],[78,15467],[79,17735],[80,18560],[81,19591],[82,20622],[83,22169],[84,23715],[85,25778],[86,27015],[87,29902],[88,31964],[89,37120],[90,41244],[91,45162],[92,49493],[93,53617],[94,61866],[95,67022],[96,75271],[97,85582],[98,104142],[99,133013],[100,null]],"name":"2013","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,1105],[62,1658],[63,2211],[64,2763],[65,3316],[66,3869],[67,4421],[68,5416],[69,5527],[70,6411],[71,6632],[72,7737],[73,8323],[74,8843],[75,9506],[76,10390],[77,11053],[78,12159],[79,13264],[80,14369],[81,15475],[82,16580],[83,17685],[84,19564],[85,21001],[86,22107],[87,24317],[88,27490],[89,28739],[90,33160],[91,35371],[92,38687],[93,44213],[94,51950],[95,59688],[96,66872],[97,85110],[98,101690],[99,165799],[100,null]],"name":"2010","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,926],[69,1274],[70,1969],[71,2548],[72,3474],[73,4516],[74,5790],[75,6068],[76,6948],[77,8106],[78,9264],[79,10191],[80,11001],[81,11580],[82,12738],[83,13896],[84,16328],[85,18528],[86,18876],[87,20844],[88,23160],[89,25476],[90,28950],[91,30456],[92,34740],[93,37751],[94,45163],[95,48637],[96,60217],[97,70639],[98,94957],[99,108853],[100,null]],"name":"2007","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,null],[69,null],[70,null],[71,null],[72,null],[73,890],[74,1526],[75,2289],[76,3179],[77,3815],[78,4070],[79,5087],[80,5850],[81,6740],[82,7631],[83,8775],[84,9411],[85,10174],[86,12718],[87,13862],[88,16533],[89,19077],[90,20349],[91,22256],[92,24164],[93,25436],[94,31031],[95,32685],[96,40697],[97,45148],[98,61681],[99,85209],[100,null]],"name":"2004","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,null],[69,null],[70,null],[71,null],[72,null],[73,null],[74,null],[75,461],[76,948],[77,1626],[78,2303],[79,2710],[80,3387],[81,4336],[82,5419],[83,6097],[84,6774],[85,7858],[86,9484],[87,10839],[88,12194],[89,13549],[90,14226],[91,16258],[92,18968],[93,20404],[94,23845],[95,27097],[96,32516],[97,39968],[98,44304],[99,52839],[100,null]],"name":"2001","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,null],[69,null],[70,null],[71,null],[72,null],[73,null],[74,null],[75,null],[76,null],[77,313],[78,590],[79,1475],[80,1771],[81,2803],[82,3689],[83,4426],[84,5902],[85,6787],[86,8263],[87,9443],[88,11066],[89,14607],[90,16230],[91,20656],[92,22132],[93,23607],[94,25968],[95,29509],[96,35411],[97,46182],[98,54592],[99,72297],[100,null]],"name":"1998","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,null],[69,null],[70,null],[71,null],[72,null],[73,null],[74,null],[75,null],[76,null],[77,402],[78,783],[79,1566],[80,1723],[81,2192],[82,2975],[83,3132],[84,3289],[85,3915],[86,4541],[87,4698],[88,6107],[89,6264],[90,7517],[91,8222],[92,9396],[93,11432],[94,13154],[95,17226],[96,19105],[97,23490],[98,31320],[99,46980],[100,null]],"name":"1995","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,null],[69,null],[70,null],[71,null],[72,null],[73,null],[74,null],[75,null],[76,null],[77,null],[78,989],[79,1258],[80,1610],[81,2012],[82,2348],[83,3019],[84,3773],[85,4193],[86,4360],[87,4696],[88,5199],[89,5870],[90,6541],[91,7044],[92,7882],[93,10230],[94,11739],[95,13417],[96,16771],[97,20125],[98,24921],[99,44610],[100,null]],"name":"1992","marker":{"enabled":false,"symbol":"circle"}},{"data":[[50,null],[51,null],[52,null],[53,null],[54,null],[55,null],[56,null],[57,null],[58,null],[59,null],[60,null],[61,null],[62,null],[63,null],[64,null],[65,null],[66,null],[67,null],[68,null],[69,null],[70,null],[71,null],[72,null],[73,null],[74,null],[75,null],[76,null],[77,null],[78,null],[79,null],[80,null],[81,null],[82,null],[83,null],[84,429],[85,933],[86,1679],[87,1866],[88,3732],[89,3732],[90,5598],[91,5598],[92,7463],[93,7463],[94,9329],[95,11195],[96,13061],[97,14386],[98,18659],[99,31720],[100,null]],"name":"1989","marker":{"enabled":false}}],"lang":{"thousandsSep":","},"meta":{"js":{"lib":{"version":"1.0.012"}},"highcharts":{"version":"4.1.8"}},"plotOptions":{"series":{"animation":true}},"pane":{"background":[]},"responsive":{"rules":[]},"subtitle":{}};/*// Sample of extending options:Highcharts.extend(options, Highcharts.merge(options, { chart: { backgroundColor: "#bada55" }, plotOptions: { series: { cursor: "pointer", events: { click: function(event) { alert(this.name + " clicked\n" + "Alt: " + event.altKey + "\n" + "Control: " + event.ctrlKey + "\n" + "Shift: " + event.shiftKey + "\n"); } } } }}));*/new Highcharts.Chart("highcharts-87315ee2-969a-4f31-b933-7b0031ae0ab0", options);}else window.setTimeout(cl, 20);}cl();})();

The graph shows that the starting point for student indebtedness keeps moving lower and lower in the distribution. In 1989, positive student indebtedness starts at the eighty-fourth percentile, meaning 16% of young families carried student debt. By 2016, the starting point was the fifty-sixth percentile, indicating that 44% of young families carried student debt.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.