Shooting Rubber Bullets at Demonstrators Is, in Fact, Lethal

Paul Rocher

Police around the world have increasingly been equipped with “nonlethal" weapons. But the myth that these weapons are harmless tools of crowd control normalizes the use of rubber bullets and tear gas against protesters — and fuels police violence that often does kill people.

National Guard Called In As Protests And Unrest Erupt Across Los Angeles Causing Widespread Damage

A police officer aims a “nonlethal” weapon as protesters raise their hands during demonstrations in the aftermath of George Floyd’s death on May 31, 2020, in Santa Monica, California. (Mario Tama/Getty Images)


The repression of France’s gilets jaunes movement showed the violent side of French policing. In a year of protests, at least twenty-four people lost an eye, five had a hand torn off, and one elderly woman was killed by a tear gas grenade. She was a victim of so-called “nonlethal” weapons — the assorted flash-balls, rubber bullets, and grenades whose use as tools of crowd control maimed dozens of demonstrators across France.

While French police are taking on an increasingly authoritarian guise — with Emmanuel Macron’s government effectively banning filming of cops — such violence against protesters is hardly just a French phenomenon. Last fall, Physicians for Human Rights reported that 115 people had suffered head injuries during the protests that followed the killing of George Floyd — again thanks to the use of nonlethal weapons.

Paul Rocher is author of Gazer, mutiler, soumettre — a book on the dangers of these weapons and the politics of “gassing, maiming, and subjugating” those who protest. He spoke to Pascual Cortés and Gonzalo García-Campo about the often-lethal danger these weapons present, their role in encouraging police to resort to violence, and why they are so compatible with the neoliberal curtailing of democratic rights.

This article is for subscribers only. Please login or subscribe to access our full archives and beautiful print and digital magazine starting at just $3 a month.